Published 6 issues per year
ISSN Print: 2152-5080
ISSN Online: 2152-5099
Indexed in
VISUALIZING UNCERTAINTY IN PREDICTED HURRICANE TRACKS
ABSTRACT
The error cone is a display produced by the National Hurricane Center in order to present its predictions of the path of a hurricane. While the error cone is one of the primary tools used by officials, and the general public, to make emergency response decisions, the uncertainty underlying this display can be easily misunderstood. This paper explores the design of an alternate display that provides a continually updated set of possible hurricane tracks, whose ensemble distribution closely matches the underlying statistics of a hurricane prediction. We explain the underlying algorithm and data structures, and demonstrate how our displays compare with the error cone. Finally, we review the design and results of a user study that we conducted as a preliminary test of the efficacy of our approach in communicating prediction uncertainty.
-
Appendini Christian M., Pedrozo-Acuña Adrián, Valle-Levinson Arnoldo, Storm surge at a western Gulf of Mexico site: variations on Tropical Storm Arlene, International Journal of River Basin Management, 12, 4, 2014. Crossref
-
Daron Joseph D., Lorenz Susanne, Wolski Piotr, Blamey Ross C., Jack Christopher, Interpreting climate data visualisations to inform adaptation decisions, Climate Risk Management, 10, 2015. Crossref
-
Lindell Michael K., Huang Shih-Kai, Wei Hung-Lung, Samuelson Charles D., Perceptions and expected immediate reactions to tornado warning polygons, Natural Hazards, 80, 1, 2016. Crossref
-
Morrow Betty H., Lazo Jeffrey K., Rhome Jamie, Feyen Jesse, Improving Storm Surge Risk Communication: Stakeholder Perspectives, Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 96, 1, 2015. Crossref
-
Wu Hao-Che, Lindell Michael K., Prater Carla S., Process Tracing Analysis of Hurricane Information Displays, Risk Analysis, 35, 12, 2015. Crossref
-
Liu L., Mirzargar M., Kirby R.M., Whitaker R., House D. H., Visualizing Time-Specific Hurricane Predictions, with Uncertainty, from Storm Path Ensembles, Computer Graphics Forum, 34, 3, 2015. Crossref
-
Sherman-Morris Kathleen, Antonelli Karla B., Williams Carrick C., Measuring the Effectiveness of the Graphical Communication of Hurricane Storm Surge Threat, Weather, Climate, and Society, 7, 1, 2015. Crossref
-
Mirzargar Mahsa, Whitaker Ross T., Kirby Robert M., Curve Boxplot: Generalization of Boxplot for Ensembles of Curves, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 20, 12, 2014. Crossref
-
Whitaker Ross T., Mirzargar Mahsa, Kirby Robert M., Contour Boxplots: A Method for Characterizing Uncertainty in Feature Sets from Simulation Ensembles, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 19, 12, 2013. Crossref
-
Cheong Lisa, Bleisch Susanne, Kealy Allison, Tolhurst Kevin, Wilkening Tom, Duckham Matt, Evaluating the impact of visualization of wildfire hazard upon decision-making under uncertainty, International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 30, 7, 2016. Crossref
-
Raj Mukund, Mirzargar Mahsa, Preston J. Samuel, Kirby Robert M., Whitaker Ross T., Evaluating Shape Alignment via Ensemble Visualization, IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, 36, 3, 2016. Crossref
-
Ruginski Ian T., Boone Alexander P., Padilla Lace M., Liu Le, Heydari Nahal, Kramer Heidi S., Hegarty Mary, Thompson William B., House Donald H., Creem-Regehr Sarah H., Non-expert interpretations of hurricane forecast uncertainty visualizations, Spatial Cognition & Computation, 16, 2, 2016. Crossref
-
Ferstl Florian, Burger Kai, Westermann Rudiger, Streamline Variability Plots for Characterizing the Uncertainty in Vector Field Ensembles, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 22, 1, 2016. Crossref
-
Liu Le, Boone Alexander P., Ruginski Ian T., Padilla Lace, Hegarty Mary, Creem-Regehr Sarah H., Thompson William B., Yuksel Cem, House Donald H., Uncertainty Visualization by Representative Sampling from Prediction Ensembles, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 23, 9, 2017. Crossref
-
Li Cheng, Shen Han-Wei, Winding angle assisted particle tracing in distribution-based vector field, SIGGRAPH Asia 2017 Symposium on Visualization, 2017. Crossref
-
Vad Viktor, Cedrim Douglas, Busch Wolfgang, Filzmoser Peter, Viola Ivan, Generalized box-plot for root growth ensembles, BMC Bioinformatics, 18, S2, 2017. Crossref
-
Dübel Steve, Röhlig Martin, Tominski Christian, Schumann Heidrun, Visualizing 3D Terrain, Geo-Spatial Data, and Uncertainty, Informatics, 4, 1, 2017. Crossref
-
Mulder Kelsey J., Lickiss Matthew, Harvey Natalie, Black Alison, Charlton-Perez Andrew, Dacre Helen, McCloy Rachel, Visualizing Volcanic Ash Forecasts: Scientist and Stakeholder Decisions Using Different Graphical Representations and Conflicting Forecasts, Weather, Climate, and Society, 9, 3, 2017. Crossref
-
Padilla Lace M., Ruginski Ian T., Creem-Regehr Sarah H., Effects of ensemble and summary displays on interpretations of geospatial uncertainty data, Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications, 2, 1, 2017. Crossref
-
Cao Yinghui, Boruff Bryan J., McNeill Ilona M., The smoke is rising but where is the fire? Exploring effective online map design for wildfire warnings, Natural Hazards, 88, 3, 2017. Crossref
-
Huang Shih-Kai, Lindell Michael K., Prater Carla S., Who Leaves and Who Stays? A Review and Statistical Meta-Analysis of Hurricane Evacuation Studies, Environment and Behavior, 48, 8, 2016. Crossref
-
Pugh Ashley J., Wickens Christopher D., Herdener Nathan, Clegg Benjamin A., Smith C. A. P., Effect of Visualization on Spatial Trajectory Prediction under Uncertainty, Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 61, 1, 2017. Crossref
-
Lindell Michael K., Communicating Imminent Risk, in Handbook of Disaster Research, 2018. Crossref
-
Sherman-Morris Kathleen, Del Valle-Martinez Idamis, Optimistic bias and the consistency of hurricane track forecasts, Natural Hazards, 88, 3, 2017. Crossref
-
Jon Ihnji, Huang Shih-Kai, Lindell Michael K., Perceptions and reactions to tornado warning polygons: Would a gradient polygon be useful?, International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 30, 2018. Crossref
-
Wellmann Florian, Caumon Guillaume, , 59, 2018. Crossref
-
Pugh Ashley J., Wickens Christopher D., Herdener Nathan, Clegg Benjamin A., Smith C. A. P., Effect of Visualization Training on Uncertain Spatial Trajectory Predictions, Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 60, 3, 2018. Crossref
-
Mirzargar Mahsa, Whitaker Ross T., Representative Consensus from Limited-Size Ensembles, Computer Graphics Forum, 37, 3, 2018. Crossref
-
Rautenhaus Marc, Bottinger Michael, Siemen Stephan, Hoffman Robert, Kirby Robert M., Mirzargar Mahsa, Rober Niklas, Westermann Rudiger, Visualization in Meteorology—A Survey of Techniques and Tools for Data Analysis Tasks, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 24, 12, 2018. Crossref
-
Rautenhaus M., Kern M., Schäfler A., Westermann R., Three-dimensional visualization of ensemble weather forecasts – Part 1: The visualization tool Met.3D (version 1.0), Geoscientific Model Development, 8, 7, 2015. Crossref
-
Gerrits Tim, Rössl Christian, Theisel Holger, An Approximate Parallel Vectors Operator for Multiple Vector Fields, Computer Graphics Forum, 37, 3, 2018. Crossref
-
Wickens Christopher D., Clegg Benjamin A., Witt Jessica K., Smith C. A. P., Herdener Nathan, Spahr Kimberly S., Model of variability estimation: factors influencing human prediction and estimation of variability in continuous information, Theoretical Issues in Ergonomics Science, 21, 2, 2020. Crossref
-
Wang Junpeng, Hazarika Subhashis, Li Cheng, Shen Han-Wei, Visualization and Visual Analysis of Ensemble Data: A Survey, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 25, 9, 2019. Crossref
-
Cheong Lisa, Kinkeldey Christoph, Burfurd Ingrid, Bleisch Susanne, Duckham Matt, Evaluating the impact of visualization of risk upon emergency route-planning, International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 34, 5, 2020. Crossref
-
Murray‐Tuite Pamela, Ge Y. Gurt, Zobel Christopher, Nateghi Roshanak, Wang Haizhong, Critical Time, Space, and Decision‐Making Agent Considerations in Human‐Centered Interdisciplinary Hurricane‐Related Research, Risk Analysis, 41, 7, 2021. Crossref
-
Pappenberger Florian, Cloke Hannah L., Baugh Calum A., Cartograms for Use in Forecasting Weather-Driven Natural Hazards, The Cartographic Journal, 56, 2, 2019. Crossref
-
Miok Kristian, Nguyen-Doan Dong, Škrlj Blaž, Zaharie Daniela, Robnik-Šikonja Marko, Prediction Uncertainty Estimation for Hate Speech Classification, in Statistical Language and Speech Processing, 11816, 2019. Crossref
-
Senkbeil Jason, Reed Jacob, Collins Jennifer, Brothers Kimberly, Saunders Michelle, Skeeter Walker, Cerrito Emily, Chakraborty Saurav, Polen Amy, Perceptions of Hurricane-Track Forecasts in the United States, Weather, Climate, and Society, 12, 1, 2020. Crossref
-
Mulder Kelsey J., Lickiss Matthew, Black Alison, Charlton‐Perez Andrew J., McCloy Rachel, Young Joseph S., Designing environmental uncertainty information for experts and non‐experts: Does data presentation affect users’ decisions and interpretations?, Meteorological Applications, 27, 1, 2020. Crossref
-
Orban Daniel, Banesh Divya, Tauxe Cameron, Biwer Christopher M., Biswas Ayan, Saavedra Ramon, Sweeney Christine, Sandberg Richard L., Bolme C. A., Ahrens James, Rogers David, Cinema:Bandit: a visualization application for beamline science demonstrated on XFEL shock physics experiments, Journal of Synchrotron Radiation, 27, 1, 2020. Crossref
-
Millet Barbara, Carter Andrew P., Broad Kenneth, Cairo Alberto, Evans Scotney D., Majumdar Sharanya J., Hurricane Risk Communication: Visualization and Behavioral Science Concepts, Weather, Climate, and Society, 12, 2, 2020. Crossref
-
MacPherson-Krutsky Carson C., Brand Brittany D., Lindell Michael K., Does updating natural hazard maps to reflect best practices increase viewer comprehension of risk?, International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 46, 2020. Crossref
-
Yao Zonghui, Dai Wenlin, G. Genton Marc, Trajectory functional boxplots, Stat, 9, 1, 2020. Crossref
-
Korporaal Michelle, Ruginski Ian T., Fabrikant Sara Irina, Effects of Uncertainty Visualization on Map-Based Decision Making Under Time Pressure, Frontiers in Computer Science, 2, 2020. Crossref
-
Lindell Michael K., Improving Hazard Map Comprehension for Protective Action Decision Making, Frontiers in Computer Science, 2, 2020. Crossref
-
Huang Zhaosong, Lu Yafeng, Mack Elizabeth A., Chen Wei, Maciejewski Ross, Exploring the Sensitivity of Choropleths under Attribute Uncertainty, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 26, 8, 2020. Crossref
-
Chen Jian, Zhang Guohao, Chiou Wesley, Laidlaw David H., Auchus Alexander P., Measuring the Effects of Scalar and Spherical Colormaps on Ensembles of DMRI Tubes, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 26, 9, 2020. Crossref
-
Correll Michael, Moritz Dominik, Heer Jeffrey, Value-Suppressing Uncertainty Palettes, Proceedings of the 2018 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, 2018. Crossref
-
Havas Clemens, Resch Bernd, Portability of semantic and spatial–temporal machine learning methods to analyse social media for near-real-time disaster monitoring, Natural Hazards, 108, 3, 2021. Crossref
-
Bica Melissa, Weinberg Joy, Palen Leysia, Achieving Accuracy through Ambiguity: the Interactivity of Risk Communication in Severe Weather Events, Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW), 29, 5, 2020. Crossref
-
Stempel Peter J., Becker Austin, Is It Scientific? Viewer Perceptions of Storm Surge Visualizations, Cartographica: The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization, 56, 2, 2021. Crossref
-
Padilla Lace, Dryhurst Sarah, Hosseinpour Helia, Kruczkiewicz Andrew, Multiple Hazard Uncertainty Visualization Challenges and Paths Forward, Frontiers in Psychology, 12, 2021. Crossref
-
Ding Qinyu, Millet Barbara, Visualizing Uncertainty in Weather Forecasts, Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 64, 1, 2020. Crossref
-
Soden Robert, Chilton Lydia, Miles Scott, Bicksler Rebecca, Villanueva Kaira Ray, Bica Melissa, Insights and Opportunities for HCI Research into Hurricane Risk Communication, CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, 2022. Crossref
-
Radford Laura, Senkbeil Jason C., Rockman Meganne, Suggestions for alternative tropical cyclone warning graphics in the USA, Disaster Prevention and Management: An International Journal, 22, 3, 2013. Crossref
-
Broos Hannah C., Stamatis Caitlin A., Goodman Zachary, Llabre Maria M., Zvolensky Michael, Timpano Kiara R., Situational uncertainty interacts with anxiety sensitivity and distress intolerance to predict anticipated worry and preparation for a hurricane, Anxiety, Stress, & Coping, 2022. Crossref
-
Liu Le, Padilla Lace, Creem-Regehr Sarah H., House Donald H., Visualizing Uncertain Tropical Cyclone Predictions using Representative Samples from Ensembles of Forecast Tracks, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 25, 1, 2019. Crossref
-
Miran Seyed M., Ling Chen, James Joseph J., People's thresholds of decision-making against a tornado threat using dynamic probabilistic hazard information, International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 42, 2020. Crossref
-
Millet Barbara, Majumdar Sharanya J., Cairo Alberto, McNoldy Brian D., Evans Scotney D., Broad Kenneth, Exploring the Impact of Visualization Design on Non-Expert Interpretation of Hurricane Forecast Path, International Journal of Human–Computer Interaction, 2022. Crossref
-
Harvey Natalie J., Western Luke M., Dacre Helen F., Capponi Antonio, Can Decision Theory Help End-Users Take the Appropriate Action in an Emergency?, Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 103, 10, 2022. Crossref
-
Holder Eli, Xiong Cindy, Dispersion Vs Disparity: Hiding Variability Can Encourage Stereotyping When Visualizing Social Outcomes, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 2022. Crossref